Tuesday, February 10, 2009

Surface Owner Legislation Being Considered

Ken Ward of the Charleston Gazette reports that a legislative interim committee is considering a Surface Owner's Bill of Rights. Presumably it is not the same as the one posted on the Surface Owner's website, which is in rough legislative form but is awkwardly written. The intent of the group is to protect the rights of surface owners who no longer own the oil and gas under their property. In many places in West Virginia, ownership of the oil and gas was severed from ownership of the surface, with the owner maintaining the surface, and oil and gas owners taking the minerals and the right to drill from the surface. When the time comes to drill, disputes can sometimes arise as to how much land can be used for the drilling site and the roads leading to it.

In my experience the oil and gas companies have worked hard with landowners to avoid disputes over surface usage, and have accommodated landowners where possible. It's not to their benefit to get into a fight with landowners, and they generally work things out. In addition, there is the Oil and Gas Production Damage Compensation Act, W. Va. Code 22-7-1 et seq. that allows landowners to receive money for damages suffered as a result of drilling activity. We'll follow the Surface Owners Bill of Rights if it is introduced in this session of the Legislature.

Monday, February 9, 2009

Environmental Rules to be Considered by LRRC

Tom Boggs of the WV Chamber of Commerce passed along the following regarding environmental rules that will be taken up by the Legislative Rule-Making Review Committee (LRRC) tomorrow. For those unfamiliar with the West Virginia rulemaking process, an explanation follows Tom's notice:

The Joint Legislative Rule-Making Review Committee will meet on Tuesday, February 10, (9:00 am - 11:00 am) in the Senate Judiciary Committee Room. The agenda is attached. This meeting is expected to be the Committee's last before the start of this year's regular legislative session. Four WVDEP rules being considered.
________________________________

45CSR1 Office of Air Quality

This rule contains ozone season Nox reduction requirements which apply to large fossil fuel-fired industrial boilers with heat inputs greater than 250mmBtu/hr. 45CSR1 also contains ozone season Nox reductin requirements for certain large cement kilns and internal combustion engines.

45CSR26 Office of Air Quality

This rule contains NOx reduction requirements which apply to electric generating units which have and electric generating capacity greater than 250 megawatts

38CSR2 Mining and Reclamation

This rule establishes general and specific rules for permit application requirements and contents; haulageways or access roads; drainage and sediment control systems; blasting; premining and postmining land use; fish and wildlife considerations; revegetation; prime farmlands; insurance and bonding; replacement, release, and forfeiture of bonds; requirements of notice of intent to prospect; performance standards; performance standards applicable to underground mining operations; subsidence control; small operator assistance program; citizen's actions; designation of areas unsuitable for mining; inspection and enforcement; Surface Mine Board; and Coal Refuse

47CSR30 Water Resources

This rule sets the requirements implementing the powers, duties, and responsibilities of the WV Code §22-11-1 with respect to all coal mines, preparation plants and all refuse and waste there from in the State

The Committee will also deal review and act on a rule under the Economic Development Office, 145CSR11, Brownfield Economic Development Districts.

Almost all rules, and all environmental rules, that are proposed in West Virginia have to be approved by the Legislature. Most of those rules are reviewed by the LRRC before they are sent on to the Legislature, where they are bundled and voted on in omnibus rules. The rulemaking process in West Virginia is rather convoluted, and at some point will be the subject of a blog entry. for the time being, if you're interested in the process, check WV Code Chapter 29A, Article 3

Thursday, February 5, 2009

Philippine Loggers and the West Virginia Economy

We often hear about the global economy and the effect local events can have half a world away. This article from the Business Mirror is a report of a crack down on illegal logging in parts of the Philippines. The reason given is the environmental importance of the intact forests for other land uses. "'We need to secure these areas from destructive elements because millions of people depend on these areas for irrigation and drinking water,' the DENR official pointed out, adding the DENR needs the support of the military in most of its tactical operations to flush out timber poachers and illegal loggers operating in the region’s forest areas. " While that is important, it bears noting that trees that are cut illegally depress the price of timber everywhere, reducing the demand for West Virginia timber to be used in furniture that is being made in the growing East Asian economies. Our timber operators in this state suffer when timber is cut cheaply elsewhere, without the operators paying taxes and engaging in necessary reforestation.

We are lucky in West Virginia to have forests that are operated in a sustainable fashion. Trees are growing faster than they are being cut. Best management practices reduce the sediment that washes into streams, and prevent increased peak flows during heavy rains. For more information about logging practices in West Virginia, and reports on forest health, try the WV Division of Forestry website.

Wednesday, February 4, 2009

Wind Largest Source of New Power in 2007

Ecogeek says that the US Department of Energy has reported that of 8.6 gigawatts of new electrical generation capacity installed in 2007, 5 gw were produced by windmills, with most of the rest supplied by natural gas. New coal plants provided about 1 gw, but with retirements of coal-fired boilers, coal -generated power shrank by 200 megawatts. The DoE put it this way:

"In 2007, for the first time, renewable energy sources, other than conventional hydroelectric capacity, accounted for the largest portion of capacity additions. Total net summer capacity increased 8,673 MW in 2007. Wind capacity accounted for 5,186 MW of this new capacity. Natural gas-fired generation accounted for 4,582 MW. Two new coal-fired plants with summer capacity totaling 1,354 MW were placed in service in 2007. However, retirements and downward adjustments to existing capacity resulted in a 217 MW net reduction in coal-fired capacity."

Interestingly, the amount of electricity generated by coal grew to its highest level ever. "In 2007, electricity generation from coal-fired capacity increased 1.3 percent, reversing the decline from 2005 to 2006. Coal-fired generation increased from 1,991 million MWh in 2006 to 2,016 million MWh in 2007. This is a new record, exceeding the previous all-time high of 2,013 million MWh set in 2005." However, "[i]n spite of setting a record level for generation in 2007, coal’s share of total net generation continued its downward trend in 2007. It accounted for 48.5 percent of total net generation in 2007 as compared to 49.0 percent in 2006 and 52.8 percent in 1997. Nevertheless, it remains the primary source of baseload generation. The decline in coal’s share of total net generation in 2007 was attributable to continued increase in the share of total net generation produced by natural gas-fired and nuclear capacity, as well as renewable sources, other than conventional hydroelectric capacity. "

An interesting development. For those interested in the details, the report can be found here. I didn't see cost comparisons of the various types of generation, but they may be somewhere in the report. It would be interesting to compare the cost of wind power, without subsidies, against other sources of power.

Residents Allege Damage to Water Supplies from Coal Slurry

The Associated Press reports that residents of Prenter in Boone County have filed suit against Massey Energy and other coal companies for allegedly poisoning their water supplies. The lawsuit states that the damage is caused by slurry, pumped from coal prep plants into underground mining voids, although that does not seem to be established yet from the scientists that were interviewed, or the DEP. These allegations are common in southern West Virginia, where water sources are often bad or unreliable regardless of mining. With luck, some of the Obama infrastructure stimulus will go to providing water lines to these people.

For those of you who are not from West Virginia and follow the hyperlink, please note that Prenter is not where the Google map indicates. That's Morgantown, where the story was filed. Boone County is in Southern West Virginia.

Monday, February 2, 2009

Fourth Circuit Allows Interstate Lawsuit Under Nuisance Theory

The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals in its State of North Carolina v. Tennessee Valley Authority decision ruled on January 13 that upwind air pollution sources can be sued by downwind states under state nuisance causes of action. One blogger has described the lawsuit in this fashion:

In the case, the State of North Carolina sues TVA under the North Carolina common law of nuisance to enjoin the way that the TVA operates its coal-fired power plants in other States, namely Tennessee, Alabama, and Kentucky. North Carolina alleges that the "lawful emissions" from the TVA’s power plants in other States travel downwind and reach North Carolina airspace, where they damage human health and the environment in North Carolina. "Even though such emissions are regulated by and in compliance with the federal Clean Air Act and State law at the location of the plants," North Carolina contends that the emissions, whether permitted under applicable statutory laws, nonetheless create a public nuisance under North Carolina common law.

You can see the rest of the entry at http://environmentalappealscourt.blogspot.com/2008/02/state-of-north-carolina-v-tennessee.html

The TVA decision by the Fourth Circuit could lead other states to bring similar actions based on that state's own nuisance law. States downwind of West Virginia may be inclined to bring such actions against West Virginia sources, to the extent that they can prove that West Virginia emissions are interfering with their attainment of air quality standards. Of course, given the complexities of air modeling, that may be more easily said than done.

National Water Quality Inventory Available from EPA.

EPA reports that the National Water Quality Inventory Report is available at http://www.epa.gov/owow/305b/2004report/. It summarizes water quality assessments submitted by the states to EPA under section 305(b) of the Clean Water Act. The report finds that the states assessed 16 percent of the nation's 3.5 million river and stream miles, 39 percent of its 41.7 million acres of lakes, ponds and reservoirs, and 29 percent of its 87,791 estuary square miles. Forty-four percent of assessed river and stream miles, 64 percent of assessed lake acres, and 30 percent of assessed estuary square miles were found to be impaired for one or more of the uses designated for them by the states. Leading causes of impairment included pathogens, mercury, nutrients, and organic enrichment/low dissolved oxygen. Top sources of impairment included atmospheric deposition, agriculture, hydrologic modifications, and unknown or unspecified sources. This report is a companion to electronically-submitted state water quality information available on EPA's Web site, known as ATTAINS, at
http://www.epa.gov/waters/ir. In addition to viewing the national summary and information by state at this Web site, users can click down to the individual waterbody level to find out more about water quality conditions.

If you're interested in the 305(b) report filed by West Virginia, the most recent on the DEP website is from 2002, although there should be reports for every 2 years since then. It provides a wealth of information about water quality in West Virginia, including program goals that may not be reflected in the EPA data summary.

For those of you who want updates from EPA on water topics, you might want to subscribe to Water Headlines. To subscribe to the Water Headlines listserve, send an email message, leave the subject line blank, and address it to waterheadlines-join@lists.epa.gov